Friday, 04 March 2011
-
"Welcome to America, Now Speak English!" (a rant about nationalism and a brief history lesson)
No wait. That's not right; this isn't England. I meant to say, "welcome to America, now speak Cherokee, Iroquois, Navajo, Sioux, Amurrrrican!"People who bitch about other people speaking in different languages always make me chuckle, but they also irritate the shit out of me. They make me chuckle because of how ignorant and stupid they are, while they irritate the shit out of me because of how ignorant and stupid they are.
Yes, if you are one of these people, this post is mostly geared towards you. So lighten the fuck up, come down off your high horse, think about what you are saying, and learn to live and let live.
At some point, a distant relative of yours made a conscious decision (unless of course they were kidnapped, enslaved, and forced) to make a journey to a foreign land, where they had to learn a new language. I can't be positive, but I'm pretty damn certain that whoever that was couldn't recite a Shakespeare sonnet in English after a few years of sweatshop labor. It was most likely the next generation, who grew up surrounded by English speakers, that was actually fluent. The immigrant generation probably knew the basics - enough to get by - while speaking their native tongue at home and among themselves.
Of course there are some familial lineages that, no matter how far back you go, remain grounded in the North American continent. So, it would seem that these people are the ones who have any legitimate right to bitch about others learning their language. Oh wait, the English speakers, and your ancestors (white people!) killed most of these folks, while all but enslaving the rest, and seized the land to form this great nation that we live in today. But it's okay though; it was all done in the name of Democracy, freedom, and tolerance.

Waves and waves of various races, ethnic groups, and nationalities came to the land of opportunity, the land of plenty, where they knew they'd be accepted for who they were because they were coming to a land where everyone was welcomed into a great melting pot.Well, no, that's not quite how it went down. But, what's important here is that most of us come from ancestries that were those "foreign-speaking (insert racial expletive here)" once upon a time. At some point, someone in our family was the new kid on the block. And they took away jobs from the "honest hard-working Americans." And they spoke a language other than English when in the company of their fellow emigrates.
There is one obvious exception: those of you who are of English ancestry. In which case, your ancestors - in addition to participating in genocide and the degradation of entire races of people - were also immigrants. But they came from the country that we fought a war of independence from. In other words, our country came into existence because of a desire to sever ties with your ancestor's former homeland.
All ties, that is, except the dress, funny wigs, ugly-ass teeth, and language. And a few more.
But let's reflect briefly on why it is that English is the unofficial official language here in the good ole USA.
England pretty much ruled the world once the Spanish empire began to decline. The English empire, and its navy, was so strong that they soon began to dominate the most coveted territory, the New World. Colonies supplied the motherland with raw materials that would fuel industry, and a market to which they could sell everything that the industry back home produced. And, of course, slaves from Africa provided the free labor that made it all the more profitable!
The Seven Years War (or French and Indian War, as the fighting in North America was called) secured the British control over what is now the US, minimizing the presence of their fellow colonizers and of the land's original inhabitants.
So, because of the fact that England was pretty much a dick to the whole world, and the best in the world at being a dick, for a few centuries, we inherited a good deal of their culture, which, of course, included their language.
So next time you want to get really possessive of your country, the invisible lines in the ground that some dude who lived long ago arbitrarily decided would give person x a different identity than person y, think about what you're saying.
Think about the fact that English comes from England.
Think about the fact that this land's original tenants spoke a wide variety of languages, most of which are virtually nonexistent now.
Think about the fact that the original Americans, the Native Americans (ha! see how much more sense that label is than "Indians") thought that the land owned them, not the other way around, and took from it what it gave.
Think about the fact that your ancestors had to learn to speak English when they first came here, and that it probably took them a while.
Think about the fact that other peoples' conversations in foreign languages aren't even really a concern of yours.
And the fact that they're probably talking about what a shithead you are anyway.
Think about the fact that America was founded on tolerance, diversity, freedom, and - oh yeah - that little thing called free speech (which, oddly enough, doesn't only apply to things you want to hear or that you can understand.)
Think about the fact that we don't even have an official national language.
But we do have an official national flower! (The rose).
And a national tree! (The oak, which unfortunately is much less regal than the UK's royal oak...)
And a national motto - E Pluribus Unim - which means "out of many, one."
Think about the fact that the only real traits that define American nationality are cultural; there is nothing at all biological linking Americans that doesn't also link humanity.
And think about the fact that nationalism is pretty stupid. To be proud of who you are and where you're from is one thing. But to feel more connected to, or to care more about the fate of, one person than another, just because of where you live in terms of an arbitrarily drawn, imaginary line, is actually quite nonsensical.
Is it REALLY true that "you gotta take care of your own first," or are just a dumb, ignorant, fuckhead?
Learn to think for yourself; think about what really matters, and challenge the notions and ideas that are grounded in nothing but tradition. Think about what is real and what is bullshit.
And now, to conclude this rant of mine, I leave you with a quote from one of the smartest men the world has ever seen:
"He who joyfully marches to music in rank and file has already earned my contempt. He has been given a large brain by mistake, since for him the spinal cord would fully suffice. This disgrace to civilization should be done away with at once. Heroism at command, senseless brutality, and all the loathsome nonsense that goes by the name of patriotism, how violently I hate all this"
-Albert Einstein
Why do you think people care what languages others speak in? Do you think that fluent English speakers who don't know any other languages have a right to be upset about what comes out of others' mouths?

Post a Comment
- Back to mancouch's Mancouch Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in mancouch's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)


Recommend


Comments (67)
I really don't care who speaks what, but it doesn't irritate me when I drive into certain ares of town, and not a single thing is in English.
I didn't read the entire post but I guess I'll give my opinion:
As far as Wikipedia is aware, English is the national language of the US, so I do believe that in order to work with customer service (especially depending on the area you live in) you should be required to speak a certain level of English. My mom was born and raised in Honduras and my grandma was born and raised in Cuba. They both came here in their 20's and yet they learned enough English to work well. Sure they have a very obvious accent but they still speak pretty fluently.
I don't have a problem with other languages. I live in Miami and people are able to get away with being Spanish-only-speakers and thats fine. However, I don't like it when they EXPECT me to know Spanish. Sure I can speak it but I'm more comfortable with English. So when they tell me, "Hey this is Miami, you have to speak Spanish." I've responded back, "And this is America, learn English."
For example, I plan on going to Japan with an ATL program and working for 5 years. In those 5 years I'm not going to expect people to speak English to me. I'll speak to them in Japanese as much as I can and I'll learn to do it fluently.
And we can talk all we want about how this is technically the Native Americans lands, and trust me, I agree. But sorry, whites took this land over forever ago and they've made it their own. Thats how life works. So sorry.
@MangoWOW@xanga - I actually agree with you. Completely. And when I went to Japan, I spoke Japanese 100% of the time, unless I was talking to my friend.
Protip, though: Don't start off with "I didn't read it all, but here's my opinion..." It drives me nuts when people do that to me, or anyone else for that matter. xP
@CastigadoR@xanga - Why is expecting people from foreign lands to speak at least a little bit of the most common language here equate to bigotry?
Speak English
http://wealthandhealth.co.cc
As one of the few people who grew up speaking English (I'm a PhD student in Chemistry) I will say it can be frustrating at times when you're studying with others who prefer to speak their native language. However, you learn to live and respect them for it. I know that I have. I enjoy learning about other people's cultures. Working with people from the Philippines, China, Vietnam, South Korea, India, Mexico and other places around the world. I know it can be hard to see jobs disappearing to people who may not be US citizens, but we gotta realize that we all have something to offer one another. Plus, these guys learned English, so what's to say I can't pick up a little Korean, Vietnamese, Chinese, etc?
We gotta give a little to get a little too.
I agree. I sometimes wonder how the people who are the most outspoken about how everyone who comes to the US should learn English would fare in another country where they didn't speak the language...I could be wrong, but sometimes, I think they're the ones who are least likely to learn the language of another country that they go to.
@MangoWOW@xanga - I also agree with you, when others speak their native tongue that's fine but when you expect me to know your language, then I get a little irritated. I have tried learning other languages and they just don't come naturally to me so I stick with what I know. At least learn enough english to get by.
And not to sound arrogant or anything, but it is a requirement to know english when it comes to air travel (pilots must know english) and this is all over the world. I know english isn't the easiest language to learn but it kinda has become the most understood language of the earth.
@Kazydai - Same here, I spoke Japanese 100% When I was in certain places in Hawaii because of a high Japanese population. This applies everywhere! When I go to Japan, do you think the Japanese are going to learn to speak English for me?? No! I am not going to learn Russian, German, or whatever for someone, speak English when you come here. You want to get mad and frustrated with us, well, we would be the same way in your country if we didn't know your language. Show some respect like we would in your country by learning a language.
yeah, i was about to read this, saw a couple of curse words in the first paragraph and decided there are better things to read.
share with you a very good website
http://www.legendstrade.com
share with you a very good website
http://www.legendstrade.com
@Kazydai - Maybe it's because usually when there are people who are obviously bigoted towards immigrants and anyone else who hasn't mastered the English language, they usually say stuff along the lines of "Learn to speak English or go back to your country!"
I was just talking about bigots in terms of people who just hate seeing an ounce of diversity, not making any generalization here, if that's what you're implying, since anyone of any walk of life can be bigoted. Over here in America, that attitude's pretty common to see among some people whenever the topic of immigration arises, not sure about where you're from.
I understand that learning the dominant language of the country is very important for anyone who is immigrating to their new country of residence in order to survive. But there are such things as racism and xenophobia, that usually segue into this topic of immigration, language barriers, assimilation, culture shock, etc. that exist, or are you from another harmonious planet? lol
Almost all other countries have a national language and it is fully expected that anyone wanting to become a citizen of their country must be able to speak their national language. America gets so many immigrants from so many different places around the world it is not even possible to accommodate all the languages that are spoken in America, and that is why we need a national language and we need to require citizens-to-be to be able to speak that national language.
All very valid points that I can agree with. I loooove the picture you
provided! I think it's quite amusing when someone is making such an
argument and they can't really speak English themselves. For someone who
wasn't born in the states I can respect both sides of the argument. I
picked up English very quickly and a lot of people can't even believe
I'm not a native to this country because I speak it so well. My friends
come to me for grammar advice all the time. However, I also really like
to learn so when I found that there was a language barrier between me
and some of my co-workers, I got a disc and started learning to speak
Spanish. No big deal. They're happy and impressed, and I get to talk to
them and feel like I can relate better. Unfortunately, it was a
different story for my parents. It's just so much more difficult to
learn another language when you're older. Heck, I know some people who
were BORN here that have difficulty speaking English, which is kinda
sad. Regardless, this is just the situation we have at hand and I think
what defines us is how we handle it. We can stick our noses up at
everyone who doesn't speak our language and yet... Would you want them
to do the same to us? Not very good for political relationships now is
it? If I ever came across someone I couldn't understand, I remind myself
to be patient because if the shoe was on the other foot, I would want
the same courtesy.
Well, I certainly don't disagree with you, but I think you could have written this less confrontationally and without so many curse words. Even though I agree with almost everything you said, talking like that is not what's going to make people want to listen to you.
What I think is that the next generation needs to start sudying foreign languages from the very beginning of Elementary school through high school. The fact is that America is one country that is way behind in terms of knowledge of other languages. In Europe, almost everyone knows English, French, and/or or German, and it is not nearly as hard to find someone who you can talk to as it would be to a non-English speaker entering America.
Lighten up, a bit, dude. Maybe a lot of those things did happen at one point in history, but this is now a completely different millenium. The socio-economic and political factors in today's society are completely different from how they were during the age of immigration in America. Though I'm sure you don't mean to and aren't aware of it, you sound to me like a bit of a hypocrite for all the negative things you said in this post about whites. Yeah, maybe there's a lot more ground for considering whites to be a relatively oppressive race compared to others, but racism is racism, regardless of what race you're insulting.
A-MEN!!!!
@danaenicole@xanga - Haha wow. Your sad, can't get past a few passionate words? Psh.
Amazing article and I completely fucking agree!
I don't care if they speak something totally different than me. What I care about is when people go to a country, and become extremely rude when you don't understand them. It will take patience a lot of the time for me to understand what you are trying to say, but being polite goes a long way to helping things move faster. The same goes goes for the other side, they are new to the country so go easy on them. Duh. Being rude just proves your an impatient moron, and it gets nobody anywhere in life.
I don't disagree with you, but I think that if someone has been here for more than 10 years, they should at least know some English by then.
I also noticed that most of the people posting against this are bilangual. I would really like to hear from someone who isn't. Who are they to say immigrants should know English when they can't even speak another language themselves. It will take time; not everyone learn at the same rate.
@MangoWOW@xanga - You didn't forget not all immigrants who built America were white did you? Also you said white people took America, yet despise Spanish..Spanish people are white. Not every white immigrant who built America spoke English, I am sure you knew that, and I am sure it took them time as well.
In my opinion, Europeans too this land a long time ago, but now it's a multicultural country, everyone should know at least know two language.
Just a small point. India was actually the most coveted land. Great Britain was not overly attached to the new world, which was in their possession due to a desire to colonise and keep it out of French hands. I am not trying to cheapen the United States victory or anything, Great Britain's power after the "War of Independence" was much the same, or to an extent even greater because they no longer had to subsidise a colony that was more a drain than anything. I believe the Brits of the time were happy for America to be independent, as long as they continued to resist the French from Canada,
I don't know if this is contrary to the history you guys are taught, but this is generally accepted amongst independent scholars. Also this:
"So, because of the fact that England was pretty much a dick to the whole world, and the best in the world at being a dick, for a few centuries, we inherited a good deal of their culture, which, of course, included their language."
Is retarded. Every country with the means to project their power outside their own borders in history has done. So get over yourself. You inherited that mantel from us. Now we can enjoy the USA being a dick to the whole world, and the USA being the best at being a dick.
Just a side point, I like America, and I like Americans. But your post is hypocritical if you think you aren't nationalist.
Short sided people make me chuckle. They also irritate the shit out of me, because of how ignorant and stupid they are. It's a common courtesy, as well as common knowledge, that if you are going to reside in a country, you should speak (or at least whole-heartedly attempt) to speak it's native tongue. I agree, that most are ignorant in this country on the subject, but only because they "bitch" about the wrong aspects. If you move to the United States of America, that does not me you should only speak English and nothing but. However, you should learn the language of the land, for yourself and others who live there. It's common courtesy and general civility. Yes it is a melting pot and that's what this country was founded on, but last time I checked, the national language was english, as well as the most used. So learn it. It's called bilingual, or trilingual, or however many languages you wish to speak. This is the same in any other country you go to. And lets not even bring the "Native Americans" into this, because this country was just a continent then, not the USA as it is now. I admire the firm stance, but you should probably get out more. Also, a proper history lesson wouldn't hurt.
@Footballblogs@xanga - Agreed.
i didn't read your post. i just wanted to tell you you're bitchin' about bitchin. lammmme :)
There should be a study done....I'm sure you'd find a strong correlation between intelligence and their stance on this topic. The only people I've talked to that expect everyone to speak english...aren't merely just ignorant...they happen to be quite dumb.