Wednesday, 06 January 2010
-
Enter the Petty Zone
(Source)
I rang in the New Year with a few friends, more than a few cans of Tecate, and the Foo Fighters greatest hits blazing in the background.
Now, you may remember the Foo Fighters from such hits as, "Everlong", "My Hero", and "Learning to Fly". Over the course of their career they have won six grammy awards, released a countless number of singles, and almost single-handedly kept the "grunge" movement alive on mainstream rock radio.
On November 3rd, 2009 the Foo Fighters released a greatest hits album, a collection of the greatest songs from their decade and a half long career.
They have officially entered "The Petty Zone"
(Source)
This is Tom Petty, an American recording artist and maybe the ugliest man on the entire fucking planet.
Tom Petty is a pillar of the rock and roll community here in America. He has at least a dozen songs that are played on FM radio stations constantly. To name a few, "Runnin' Down A Dream'", "American Girl", "Breakdown", and of course "Free Fallin".
Think of all those hit Tom Petty songs. Now try and name one classic Tom Petty album. I'd wager most of you can't do it. I'd wager one of you, is sitting in front of the screen shouting "Damn the Torpedoes!", "Damn the Torpedoes!"
Nope. Not cutting it. "Damn the Torpedoes" was Petty's third album, released in 1979 and was by far his best selling and most important record. How many singles charted? Three. None of which ended up cracking the Billboard top ten. While that's no means bad, it hardly qualifies it as amazingly successful.
The point is, Petty has put together an impressive career slowly. At the time of this post, Tom Petty both with the Heartbreakers and solo, has 13 studio albums. Most of which are filled with songs that are for the most part, forgettable. But, for 11 songs that miss, Petty nails one classic.
I'm calling it the Tom Petty Zone, bands without a defining album that will have, or in Petty's case already have, a killer greatest hits collection.
With the release of their greatest hits album, the Foo Fighters have entered the Petty Zone.
Here are a few other bands and recording artists who I think are worth of a Petty Zone nomination:
Weezer: I think the Blue Album was incredible, so maybe that disqualifies them, but the post Blue Album stuff has had just enough hits to keep them interesting while most everything else sucks. Hash Pipe, anyone?
Ludacris: I don't want to only focus on suburban white boy rock. Everytime I hear a Ludacris song on the radio, or at a party it's good stuff. He's for sure a hit maker.
The Who: My Dad might kill me for saying this, but I really don't think any album by The Who is particularly fantastic. But add up the best parts of their catalog, and boy, you've got a winner. I'm sure they'll show you what I mean at halftime of the Super Bowl.
Beyonce Knowles: Dear Lord. This woman is a fucking hit machine. Between Destiny's Child and her solo career, you have enough material for a Greatest Hits box set. But still, I don't think Beyonce has ever nailed a classic album. I might be wrong though, I don't really own any Beyonce albums.
Last but not least, I really want to put down The Red Hot Chili Peppers, but I think they probably don't qualify. The Peppers are just in a league of their own, seeing as how both "Blood Sugar Sex Magic" and "Californication" were huge, yet their Greatest Hits album will be even huger. I mean they've had like 600 singles over the years and they all kick ass.
Let's hear it, who else is headed to the Petty Zone?
Post a Comment
- Back to mancouch's Mancouch Site!
- Note: your comment will appear in mancouch's local time zone: GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)














Comments (15)
haha my friend ashley petty is related to him.
I guess I must be the only one between the two of us who loved Foo Fighters' first album.
I suddenly feel quite old and behind the times.
Doesn't Mariah Carey do this? She's had a lot of hits, but they've been spread out over the years. Maybe others disagree, but usually her singles are the good songs, and the others are just filler space.
Ever listened to the Colour and the Shape? It's a great album. The Foo Fighters have not always been a "singles" band, and I'd even dispute the label of "grunge."
@mynameisblueskye@xanga - I like their first one, too, but I think their second's even better.
Does anyone think this blog also sounds a lot like a missing part of Sick Boy's unified theory of life? (For those confused, rent Trainspotting.)
Three Days Grace. Can't write a song worth a damn if it's not a single. GREAT SINGLES, THOUGH!
I'm so in love with Tom Petty. WHAT a fantastic musician. Also, fun fact- Dave Grohl was invited to join the Heartbreakers, but declined. Wild.
EVERLONG!!! <3
Tom petty isn't that bad looking.
The Colour And The Shape is a great album. front to back. Besides, i would say most bands strive to have that definitive album and spend their whole careers trying to make it. Very few actually achieve that. I would say Zeppelin came close to that most of the time. But even they have some songs on their albums that I could do without. If u r a big fan of a band (like I am of the Foo's), then u have more of an appreciation for all their albums. If u r a casual fan, then u probably just enjoy what's on the radio (Everlong, Learn To Fly, etc.). Most bands put out greatest hits albums as a way to fulfill their record contract. They are good compilations for the casual fan, but the hardcore fan just goes on itunes and downloads the unreleased songs.
I don't listen to Petty enough to name his albums, but actual fans of him surely can.
As for Foo Fighters, I consider their best album to be "Echoes, Silence, Patience and Grace"; by far.
she grew up in an indiana town, had a good lookin mama who never was around. but she grew up tall and she grew up right with them indiana boys on them indiana nights.
i agree with your nominations. i may throw young jeezy on there, because i really want to like him as an artist, but besides his good songs, the rest suck.Weezer is definitely on this list! I also think The Killers. They've had songs like "Mr. Brightside", "When You Were Young" and "Spaceman" that were pretty popular.
Foo is my absolute favorite band. Yes, I agree that the Colour and the Shape was definitely a strong album. It single-handedly brought us the hits "My Hero", "Monkey Wrench", and of course, the beloved "Everlong."
But while I think it is one of the strongest albums ever, I don't know anyone else who actually owns all of Foo's cd's except me. I know a ton of people who "fuckin' love Foo Fighters, man!" but none of them own a single cd.
Indeed, they have entered the Petty zone. However, I don't believe that is a bad thing. All of their songs are great, and they EASILY put out a Greatest Hits cd that was badass and a half, and even that was missing some of the songs I was really hoping it would have.
The Petty zone is a good thing. It means people like your music...
You just don't have one single cd that defines you.
I have every Foo Fighters album and EP, and I would say they've had 4 definitive albums, each influential in its own way. In comparison to a lot of their later stuff, the first album was forgettable. Good, but forgettable. The Color and the Shape, as everyone has said, was amazing. One by One moved to a much more distorted, darker sound than the first three, which was actually quite amazing, but then for the next two albums, In Your Honor and Echoes and Silence, they turned that over on it's head again. All of the albums I've mentioned are pretty much amazing. So no, I would say that the Foos definitely do not belong in the Petty zone.