Thursday, 18 June 2009

  • Why Facebook Should Be Segregated

    I remember back in the day when Facebook was just a futuristic web contraption designed to let you hunt down the ladies you met the night before whose names you couldn't remember. It was an easier time then. You could browse the fellow students in your classes. You could put your pictures up and never fear the wrong folks'd see 'em. It was designed by college students for college students to connect with other college students at the colleges they went to and even the colleges they didn't.

    When I was in high school, Facebook was one of the few lights at the end of a long and miserable tunnel; the minute you accepted that high school diploma, you were handed a college email address, which in those days was the requirement for joining. Facebook was a rite of passage, something that a pizza-faced high school freshman could never understand. If high schoolers wanted a social networking site they could have easily joined myspace: all the pedophiles did!


    Exhibit A


    Then came High School Facebook. Hell hath no fury like my own against High School Facebook, or HSFB as it may have been called at one point. At first we were told that HSFB would never, ever bleed into the original. We allowed Mark Zuckerberg and his minions to expand their business because we trusted them. We were all of us deceived.

    Suddenly I was being "Friended" by the little brats whose only interaction with me had been a "Scram!" or a "Get lost, ya ruffian!" I knew that these children would never intend to actually be friends with me; they simply sought acknowledgment from an elder, in this case one who had graduated from his alma mater with the reputation of being a bad ass: moi.


    I took my dog and a sawed-off to Senior Prom.

    So I was Friends with some little redheaded kid I'd kicked the crap out of in high school. All he wanted was my approval, not my attention. A few days later and I was friends with nearly as many people I didn't know as those I did. No big deal, I guess. Let the little bastards see all the pictures of me doing the stuff they wished they could be doing. You know. Mature stuff that adults do. Like keg stands and beer bongs.

    And then Mark Zuckerberg (more like Mark Suckerberg!) pulled another fast one on us. Anyone, and I mean anyone, can now create a Facebook account. I know this because my father is on it. My father who doesn't believe in mousepads, who has never successfully navigated OnDemand cable, who is OLD AS ALL HELL, is on Facebook. Don't get me wrong, I love my father. He is a wonderful, kind man, and incredibly smart as well. I would trust him with anything important. But Facebook is not important, Dad. You're not missing anything, I promise!

    That's the point I've been trying to get at throughout this whole post: Facebook isn't important! It is a great place to keep up with friends and meet new ones. But parents, politicians, recruiters: stay out.


    "Am I Tweeting yet?! Am I?!"

    You're told that if you use anything less than the strictest security settings you will be putting your future in jeopardy. Not only are we losing access to many of the memories we've made throughout college--any picture of you at a party or holding a drink can be used against you--but we are also losing a tremendous amount of self-expression. The programmers at Facebook, all young people like us, have sacrificed privacy and trust in the name of expanding their empire, pushing for more and more ad revenues via applications, company pages, and the like.


    "I just sold your privacy on eBay!"

    Facebook was once a means of embracing the newfound independence and self-expression found upon graduating high school and moving out of your parent's house. Now it's become a hiring pool, crippling that independence as a means of preparing us for the workforce before we've even joined it. The person I am on Facebook, ostensibly a place to meet people and keep up with friends, should never have to be the person I am in an interview. Neither instance is the real me, but both are ways that I present myself to different groups of people. Even that red-headed punk from my high school knows: being my Friend doesn't make you my friend.

    We are all met with a dilemma. The easiest solution would be for me to delete Facebook. But the sad reality is that I, like many of us, am totally dependent on it. Without Facebook around I'd forget my friends' birthdays, their phone numbers and email addresses. I'd lose hundreds of memories, represented by the pictures posted of me during college.

    I'm not asking for adults to get off, either. I just don't understand why we all have to use the same Facebook? If Mark Zuckerberg had kept his promise about the separation between Facebooks, our parents could use it to connect with their high school and college friends without being able to monitor us--which they do, whether or not they intend to.

    That's why Facebook should be segregated. There, I said it. High School Facebook should not be integrated into College Facebook which should never be integrated with whatever comes after college. Old People Facebook. My advice to you, Mark Zuckerberg, is to divide up your empire before it collapses from utter suckitude.

Comments (47)

  • MochaMoose230@xanga

    the family trees that keep sprouting up on facebook disgust me... My friend is a freshmen in college... her 9 year old sister just made a facebook [which she listed her age as 19 on btw], as well as her 42 year old mother whose profile picture is basically centered on the new fake boobs she bought.
    wrong... just wrong.

  • jakkie_paints_in_purple@xanga

    I've been on facebook since I was a junior in high school?? I think? Something like that. I had a friend in college on it.  So its been about a year and a half since I made it and since then my mother, stepdad, aunt, uncle, and may other family members have made one.  My two older college age cousins were already on.  I refuse to add my parents.  I have my aunt because she friended me.  It bugs me that my parents are there and all their friends.  There are other sites out there that they could be on but no it has to be facebook

  • B_Marclar@xanga

    Normally, I'm not a fan of segregation, but you raise a great point.

  • Filmwarr@xanga

    This is arguement is just as annoying to me as I'm sure kids and old people on FB are to you. If you don't know them, if you talked to them once in your life, and they try to add you, you IGNORE it. If you add your mom to appease her CHANGE YOUR PRIVACY SETTINGS so that she can only see a limited profile. 

    Facebook is not the closed community it once was. It's opened avenues and is uniting people together from hundreds of different countries into one medium. At the same time, it's a open avenue you can CONTROL.I just don't understand the resentment.
  • TheSpaceBass@xanga

    @Filmwarr@xanga - I do not understand as well.

    Sigh, facebook.

  • Seen_More_Spine_in_Jellyfish@xanga

    exactly why i deleted my facebook! I dont have one nor do I have any drama!

  • mattsmee@xanga
    That was one's decision when adding someone one don't really know. People went crazy about families old people etc joining FB. That has nothing to do with your privacy actually. If you don't know someone very well and don't give a s**t to refuse their friend-request, just ignore them. If you are afraid of someone, maybe your mom, asking "hey son why don't you accept me as friend on FB?" you can add her into limited profile list. Or creating "lists" to group people. You can always take control of which lists/groups of friends have access to your stuff.
    Go through all the setting carefully so you can always be sure that "the nasty photos" won't be viewable to someone.
    Why people got so annoyed?
    BTW some people on FB uploaded "stupid" stuff and their friends complained "dang it, don't tag me on the photos my boss would've seen it". THIS IS YOUR SETTING that went wrong! Remember, everything (except your name) on FB can be set to hide from anyone you specify. And you take the full control, not by anyone. Just stop complaining and learn how to use FB folks.
  • peace_quotes_nd_love@xanga

    haha corrrect. i hate how what we choose to put on our facebook can be used against us. i think we should be able to have a life and connect with people WITHOUT ALWAYS being watched and judged. you screw up once, show a bad picture & your job sees it --- your futures over.

  • yourblondeness@xanga

    @Filmwarr@xanga - Agreed.

    OP, learn to use your facebook. Set your general security settings to the maximum so possible employers can't see things they shouldn't. Then, when someone friends you, you can set INDIVIDUAL security, so you can limit specifically what your mother sees. It's not difficult at all.

  • jolee121910@xanga

    i use high privacy settings. it is pretty annoying to set them, but yea. same for photo albums. certain things opened only to the people i want.

  • MangoWOW@xanga

    Facebook should have been kept as college students only! I hate seeing all these little high school kids and teeny boppers around. And then the OLD PEOPLE! BLEH!
    I only add people I actually know and talk to though.

  • scrambledmegzntoast@hardestlevel

    Facebook is pointless and run and populated by idiots. Like...

    @MangoWOW@xanga - High school should have been kept as college students only!

    The brilliant observations never quite stop with you, do they? Now. Time for your snappy comeback, genius. By the way, does your profile image just keep getting uglier (and trashier) or is it just you?

  • MangoWOW@xanga

    @scrambledmegzntoast@hardestlevel - Wow.... that wasn't trollish at all. Quite the peacekeeper, aren't ya?

  • scrambledmegzntoast@hardestlevel

    @MangoWOW@xanga - Heehee, a "wow" and a cliche that I thought was only used by 50-years-olds, all in one post!

  • MangoWOW@xanga
  • scrambledmegzntoast@hardestlevel

    @MangoWOW@xanga - Yes, because I knew you would be commenting on this post, genius. Hardly. I decided to play with you because you are a ridiculously easy target. 

  • MangoWOW@xanga

    @scrambledmegzntoast@hardestlevel - ah okay. So trolling. Tell me how that turns out, kay? 

  • scrambledmegzntoast@hardestlevel

    @MangoWOW@xanga - OMG. You're high, aren't you? You have no idea who I am. You have started fights with me like three different times. I didn't just decide to pick on you, randomly. You spend all your time starting arguments on people's blogs then you make comments about how much better you think you are than people my age, but you're like 20 and you're a perpetually drunk/stoned community college dropout. That's great! Did you just take that profile picture in your current state?

  • MissPixieGlitter@xanga

    the moment "high school" facebook came around, anyone could join. parents aren't the new addition, they were just slower to the punch. anyway, if those kids annoy you so damn much, frickin stop adding them.

  • MangoWOW@xanga

    @scrambledmegzntoast@hardestlevel - .... are you confusing me with someone else? We argued once in that momaroo blog. We acknowledge each other in one other blog and besides that I've been actively keeping myself from replying to you. Even then, both of those times it was you who started up with me. And while I should problably refrain from defending myself from someone like you (I'm sure this is exactly what you want) I'd have to say, I'm not a regular drinker or drug user by any means. I think I even mentioned it in one of my latest blogs. And I currently attend University (and thinking about applying to one in Chicago now). I have no idea where you're getting your info but you obviously havent stopped by my blog (I'm not complaining). I don't necisarily think I'm better than people your age, but right now I do think I'm better than you. Good bye because I'm not responding again. I think you've made it obvious that you're here to bother and thats fine with me.

  • scrambledmegzntoast@hardestlevel

    @MangoWOW@xanga - Yeah, whatever. The true you will show up soon enough. Now go see if you can find a blog where someone's kid was killed or something and start a meaningless fight for your own amusement. I will keep bothering you because you are contemptible and that deserves to be shown. 

  • Auxesis@xanga

    Facebook is shit anyway. So is Myspace. Social networking is only good when you're really really bored. It's more overrated than oral sex. 

  • Winterwhiterose@xanga

    Same reaction when MY mum joined facebook.

  • mancouch

    @scrambledmegzntoast@hardestlevel - Please stop trolling... it's stupid.

  • scrambledmegzntoast@hardestlevel
  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

  • New! You can now edit your comments for 15 minutes after submitting.